no terror

Music Playlist at


same old crap

what is this 55?

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

is this disgraceful?

you can read the prologue of my post in someone else's words here.

in continuation to my comment there; i heard that some performances back or episodes back, saroj khan had humiliated bakhtiyar in a very crude fashion. although i believe that a person could never act above his or her person level, but there should be some grace at the level khan is at.

but it was a sad win for the girls, nonetheless. they didn't deserve it. and i feel they still got the respect from the guys. i draw this particular conclusion from the fact that delnaaz stopped her brother from sharply retaliating to the unsavory criticism from the judges, when boys had concluded their ultimate act, by silent gestures. she (and the girls) understood every bit of his (their) reaction. and also, it seemed, that each of the girl understood that it was not a disgraceful act of immature knee-jerk reaction but a humble although passionate solicitation against the usage of uncouth words from a senior judge [which saroj khan, malaika and pandey were very well aware of, thus their acrid words].

another related link



Blogger spicymist said...

reality show judges are too harsh sometimes. they don't have much actual work to do and hence the judging. these people dancing are quite famous too . you cant insukt them this publicly:-|
one such no good loser i need to mention is anu malik . the way he insults people in Indian Idol. its like he is the God of music or something. funny considering He was accused most of ripping off music frm english versions.

10/08/2008 01:01:00 PM  
Anonymous burf said...

anu malik - i detest him so much that he looks funny to me

10/10/2008 11:02:00 AM  
Blogger Phoenix said...

Saroj Khan's comments to bakhtiyar came after the final performance, after an argument, and since she wasnt on the judge ever except for the final, they cdnt have had a history. That apart, the girls just acted more maturely by not fighting on stage, by not reacting and choosing to stay gracefully silent. The boys cd have done that, protest off stage, thru media et al, howmuchever u want to after the show, but this behavior wd just bring criticism that they are whining after losing. Unsportsmanlike. there was anyway a walkout after the 4th round, n they must have been brought back by the show producers who have momney riding on a four hour show, other things that did not happen on camera. This needn't have, as well. Not by celebrities on tv.
the girls danced better in the final. Watch the videos if u will. but that's not the point anyway.

10/13/2008 01:52:00 AM  
Anonymous burf said...

"they cdnt have had a history":-
as per some other reports on net, it seems that saroj khan and bakhtiyar did have some kind of unhappy history.

"the girls just acted more maturely by not fighting on stage":-
actually this was not a fight between girls and boys, it was between guys and uncouth judgment.

"protest off stage, thru media et al":-
nothing would have generated as much interest as the on-stage protest did

"his behavior would just bring criticism that they are whining after losing":-
i have seen more support than criticism of their "whining"

"brought back by the show producers":-
true, as they say it is all about money honey

girls looked better dancers because guys had already walked off, at least mentally (who knows they might have been threatened by producers to come back on stage), but that is not the point - as you said

10/13/2008 10:43:00 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home